not everything needs a silver lining

i’ve grown increasingly uncomfortable with our need to make beautiful things out of other people’s suffering.

the need to find the lesson. the purpose. the testimony. the little glimmer of goodness that somehow makes the terrible thing a little more digestible.

i understand why we do it.

it’s uncomfortable to sit in the presence of pain that we cannot fix. it’s uncomfortable to acknowledge that something devastating can happen to someone without us being able to offer an explanation. and i think, particularly as christians, we sometimes feel an obligation to make suffering make sense in order to protect our understanding of the goodness of god.

but i wonder how much additional suffering we’ve unintentionally inflicted on people in our attempts to do that.

when i lost my babies, i didn’t need someone to tell me that everything happened for a reason.

i needed my babies.

and there wasn’t a combination of words in the english language that could change the reality of that.

there are experiences in this life that leave you with nowhere to put your love. you had imagined an entire future with someone, and suddenly you’re left carrying all the affection you had already begun cultivating for a life that will never unfold the way you imagined.

what are you supposed to do with all of that love?

where does it go?

i don’t think people realize that pregnancy loss isn’t just the loss of a pregnancy. it’s the loss of a whole collection of ordinary moments that will never happen. the birthdays. the fingerprints on the windows. the little shoes by the front door. the personality you never got to discover.

it’s grieving someone you knew so intimately without ever having the opportunity to really know them.

and then you’re expected to return to your life.

there is something almost offensive about how ordinary the world remains in the aftermath of a personal tragedy. people are buying groceries. they’re laughing. they’re complaining about traffic. the sun is still rising and setting as though nothing has happened.

and to them, nothing has.

but your entire world is different.

i think that’s why i’ve grown to appreciate the people who are willing to sit in the ugliness of things with me. the ones who don’t scramble to find the right words. who don’t feel the need to steer the conversation toward something positive. who allow the weight of something to simply be what it is.

because sometimes there is nothing more loving than admitting that you don’t know what to say and that things just plain suck.

i’ve been thinking a lot about the difference between believing that god can redeem suffering and believing that suffering needed to happen in order for something good to exist.

those aren’t necessarily the same thing.

i can acknowledge that my losses cultivated a deeper tenderness in me without believing that my babies needed to die in order for me to become a more compassionate person.

i can recognize the ways god has met me in my pain without attributing the pain itself to some divine lesson i was supposed to learn.

i can find beauty in the aftermath without calling the devastation beautiful.

and i think that distinction matters.

sometimes i wonder if our obsession with turning pain into a testimony makes people feel like they have to earn the suffering they’ve endured. as though they owe the world something inspirational in exchange for having survived it.

what if you’re not ready to tell your story?

what if you never find the lesson?

what if something happened to you, and years later all you can really say about it is that it hurt?

i don’t think that makes your faith any less profound.

one of the things i love most about scripture is that it hasn’t been sanitized of human anguish. there are entire passages dedicated to lament. there are cries of desperation and questions that aren’t immediately answered. there are people who love god and are utterly bewildered by what is happening to them.

and their words were deemed worthy of preservation.

god allowed their grief to occupy space in scripture.

i find so much comfort in that.

it reminds me that i don’t have to make my pain spiritually presentable before bringing it to him. i don’t have to end every prayer with a declaration of how grateful i am for the thing that is breaking my heart.

sometimes my prayer can simply be that my heart is broken.

i think there is holiness in that kind of honesty.

now that i have my son, i sometimes think about the temptation to wrap my story up in a beautiful little narrative. three losses followed by a healthy baby. the valley followed by the mountaintop. the years of waiting followed by the answered prayer.

but my son is not the silver lining of my miscarriages.

he is his own person. his own little life. his own beautiful story.

and so were the babies i lost.

his existence doesn’t retroactively make their absence okay. i don’t love them any less because i finally have someone to hold. and i don’t need to diminish the grief of losing them in order to fully celebrate the joy of having him.

both have a home in me.

i think that’s what healing has begun to look like in my life. not the replacement of sorrow with joy, but the expansion of my heart to accommodate both.

i still believe in redemption. i still believe in the goodness of god. i still believe that he is capable of bringing life out of the most desolate places.

but i no longer feel the need to find a justification for every terrible thing that happens on this side of eternity.

some things are terrible because we live in a broken world.

some things will ache for the entirety of our earthly lives.

and some things we will carry to the feet of jesus without ever having understood them.

until then, i hope we learn how to sit beside each other in the ashes without being in such a hurry to point out the flowers.

they’ll bloom when they bloom.

and there is someone sitting beside you who needs to be loved in the meantime.

with love,

brooke

the gentle portion

Next
Next

mourning a woman who is still alive